Tarragona, Biblioteca pública, Ms. 69

1r-176r, Benedict of Aniane - Concordia regularum

Link to digitization: here.
PLENKERS 1906, p. 15 and 17 sq.; STRECKER 1951, p. 167 (manuscript T; with the wrong date and location “noch im 10. Jh. in Frankreich geschrieben”); DOMÍNGUEZ Y BORDONA 1952, p. 13 (“Siglo X”; with the assumption that this manuscript formed part of the original donation from Grandselve to Santes Creus), 17 and 67; DOMÍNGUEZ Y BORDONA 1953–1954, p. 56; MUNDÓ I MARCET 1974, p. 18 (with the wrong date “segle XIV”); ALTÉS I AGUILÓ 1983, p. 33; MUNDÓ I MARCET 1988, p. 111 sq. with n. 76 and 78 (“siglo IX y quizás de su primera mitad … falta de influencias visigóticas … copiado en algun importante escritorio del centro de Francia, sin que pueda precisar más … no sería extraño, en pura hipótesis, que los monjes cistercienses compraran la ‘Concordia’ a este monasterio [sc. “Ripoll”]”); ALTURO I PERUCHO 1991b, p. 43 (“en torno al año 900”); ALTURO I PERUCHO 1991c, p. 278 with n. 11 (“de cap a l’any 900”); BONDÉELLE-SOUCHIER 1991, p. 126 sq. (with the wrong date “X”); JULLIEN/PERELMAN 1994, p. 215 (“IXe”); LEMAITRE 1996, p. 26; BONNERUE 1999, p. 47 n. 105, p. 67 (“de Santa Cruz”), p. 168 sq., 171 sq. and 196 (manuscript T; with the wrong date “Xe s.”); RIERA I MELIS 1999, p. 165 fig. (fol. 1r; with the wrong date “segle X–XI”); ZIMMERMANN 2003, 1, p. 582 sq. (who speculates following Domínguez y Bordona that it could have belonged to the primitive dotation of Santes Creus because its first abbot Guillem was before the prior of the Southern French mother abbey Grandselve); ZIMMERMANN 2003, 2, p. 763 (“il semble originaire du Centre de la France, où il aurait été transcrit dans la première moitié du IXe siècle”; he refers here also to Jesús Alturo’s palaeographical opinion that the copy could be written in Catalonia between 880 and 900 und would thus be one of the earliest Catalan manuscripts in perfect [!] Caroline minuscule; yet this does not fit to this style of Caroline minuscule); ZELZER 2004, p. 365 n. 2 (“9. Jh.”); MORDEGLIA 2008, p. 464 n. 24 (“sec. X”); MIRANDA Y GARCÍA 2015, p. 33 with n. 40 (with the wrong date “siglo X”); ENGELBERT 2016b, p. 139 with n. 5 (“saec. X”). The inventory of Santes Creus of the last quarter of the 12th century has “Instituta monachorum . continens secum alcuinum et vitam beati mauri”, Catalogus codicum manuscriptorum Sanctarum Crucium saec. XII4/4, p. 16 no 31, which ZIMMERMANN 2003, 1, p. 583 identifies with the work of Benedict of Aniane (“sans doute l’œuvre de Benoît d’Aniane”; no identification ZIMMERMANN 2003, 2, p. 758 with n. 435, but ibid., p. 763 and 824 then with the Concordia regularum). The manuscript is not mentioned by BISCHOFF 2014, p. 364. Digitization: http://bibliotecatarragona.gencat.cat/ca/bpt_recursos_de_la_consulta/bpt_colleccions_digitalitzades/.